| Year | Name |
| 1836-37 | John W. Wiley |
| 1836 | Josiah Barber, Ohio City |
| 1837, 1842 | Francis A. Burrows, Ohio City |
| 1838-39 | Norman C. Baldwin, Ohio City |
| 1838-39, 1842 | Joshua Mills |
| 1840 | Nicholas Dockstader |
| 1840-41 | Needham M. Standart, Ohio City |
| 1841 | John W. Allen |
| 1843 | Nelson Hayward |
| 1843 | Richard Lord, Ohio City |
| 1844-45, 1857-58 | Samuel Starkweather |
| 1844-1846 | Daniel H. Lamb, Ohio City |
| 1846 | George Hoadley |
| 1847 | Josiah A. Harris |
| 1847 | David Griffith, Ohio City |
| 1848 | Lorenzo A. Kelsey |
| 1848 | John Beverlin, Ohio City |
| 1849 | Flavel W. Bingham |
| 1849-50 | Thomas Burnham, Ohio City |
| 1850-51 | William Case |
| 1851-52 | Benjamin Sheldon, Ohio City |
| 1852-54 | Abner C. Brownell |
| 1853-54 | William B. Castle, Ohio City |
| 1855-56 | William B. Castle |
| 1859-60, 1864 | George B. Senter |
| 1861-62 | Edward S. Flint |
| 1863-64 | Irvine U. Masters |
| 1865-66 | Herman M. Chapin |
| 1867-70 | Stephen Buhrer |
| 1871-72 | Frederick W. Pelton |
| 1873-74 | Chas. A. Otis |
| 1875-76 | Nathan P. Payne |
| 1877-78, 1891-92 | William G. Rose |
| 1879-82 | Rensselaer R. Herrick |
| 1883-84, 1899-1900 | John H. Farley |
| 1885-86, 1889-90 | George W. Gardner |
| 1887-88 | Brenton D. Babcock |
| 1893-94 | Robert Blee |
| 1895-98 | Robert E. McKisson |
| 1901-09 | Tom L. Johnson |
| 1910-11 | Herman C. Baehr |
| 1912-15 | Newton D. Baker |
| 1916-1919, 1934-35 | Harry L. Davis |
| 1920-21 | William S. Fitzgerald |
| 1922-23 | Fred Kohler |
| 1924-29 | William R. Hopkins, City Manager |
| 1930-31 | Daniel E. Morgan, City Manager |
| 1932-33 | Ray T. Miller |
| 1936-1940 | Harold H. Burton |
| 1941 | Edward Blythin |
| 1942-45 | Frank J. Lausche |
| 1946-53 | Thomas A. Burke |
| 1954-61 | Anthony J. Celebrezze |
| 1962-67 | Ralph S. Locher |
| 1968-71 | Carl B. Stokes |
| 1972-77 | Ralph J. Perk |
| 1978-79 | Dennis J. Kucinich |
| 1980-88 | George V. Voinovich |
| 1989- | Michael White |